Welcome to this page
dedicated to inkjet printers and ink--- the NO BALONEY review and
info page. Almost EVERY commercial and even non-commercial printer review and
inkjet info shortchanges the consumer- and ignores long term usage
problems, and practical application of printers and ink.
PAGE LOOKS AT EVERYTHING beyond the superficial claims and typical shallow
reviews- typical reviews that GREATLY MISLEAD users and buyers of inkjet
printers and ink.
info on the new season of Canon printers is down the page, in which I compare
with last year's superlative models.
One complaint about my site that I saw on
another site reviewing REVIEW SITES was that this site did not reflect the
newest printers in the market.
That is correct.
And there is a reason for this:
I am still using printers made a couple of
years ago-- and the cost of using these older printers, including the EASE of
using these printers is MUCH BETTER than the newest models.
1) Canon generally makes the best printers
for consumers, and this has been the case for several years. My older Canon
printers work fine, and I have not been able to find ANY reason for replacing
them. New printers DO NOT WORK BETTER than my original ip model printers.
PERIOD. There are reasons why the new printers are WORSE (keep reading). Any
change in resolution or color rendition is absolutely un-detectable.
2) Canon began changing the STYLE of the INK
CARTRIDGES so that all new printers use ELECTRONIC CHIPPED cartridges. This is
how Epson for years has for years made the use of aftermarket cartridges
extremely difficult- and thus EXPENSIVE for the consumer. Canon has followed
suit-- and thus, using inexpensive aftermarket cartridges requires transferring
the chip from an original Canon cart to the aftermarket cart, and half the time
this does not even work as claimed.
3) Very good aftermarket ink for 6BCI style
cartridges (older style) is easily found, at a FRACTION of the price for an
official Canon cart. Further, BULK ink, of even better quality at even lower
cost is easily found, and one can REFILL either Canon or aftermarket carts to
great success--- EVEN IN NEW PRINTER CARTS like 8CLI style carts (new Canon
printers). Contrary to rumors-- THERE IS NO INCREASED PRINTER RISK IN USING GOOD
BULK INK OR GOOD AFTERMARKET CARTS.
4) Quality and use of new printers is NOT
IMPROVED over printers like ip3000, ip4000, ip5000, ip6000.
5) My current recommendation is to find a
like-new ip3000, ip4000, ip5000, ip6000, or ip6000D on Craigslist or ebay and
continue to use the 6BCI type cartridges for which aftermarket alternatives
remain easily obtained. These are EXCELLENT printers in terms of quality, speed,
reliability, and certainly MUCH BETTER in regards to good economy of ink. In
fact, I just bought a NEW IN THE BOX ip3000 printer- December 2007. I wouldn't
trade this for ANY new model Canon (or any other brand) printer if given to me
1) Don't go broke
buying overpriced inkjet refills.
We have now found suppliers who actually offer ink cartridges at fair prices.
retailer, and most internet sources we have found charges at least 300% to
600% times the price of these companies. We've tested their inks- they
work wonderfully, and
a fraction of the cost of the OEM ink you pay through the nose for.
These are NOT
paid endorsements in any way, just passing on our research in this area, more details
We've tested several custom formula third party inks against Canon (and some
Epson) factory ink cartridges and there
is little reason- except for greed- that anyone should be paying $20- $60 to refill
their inkjet printers. It is obscene. Details below on this page.
But what about
SPAN of cheap second party inks? SEE THIS PAGE for my comments then read the
pages in Ink Jet Ink then read this page on
2) For large quantities of
printing by professionals and artists, REFILL
your cartridges for a fraction of store bought carts. Details
use off the shelf refill kits, however. Your ink will cost you1/20th the price
of regular refills. There are Continuous Flow Systems available- these
come with their own set of problems however, again details below...
If you need a printer, I suggest any
Canon desktop regular printer at the mid-price range, $79- $99 or more
that takes at least 5 cartridges. i.e. models ip3600, ip4600, ip4700, or any pro
Do not buy a printer that
uses one black and one combo Tri-color cartridge.
Good older printers may
occasionally be found such as
ip3000, ip4000, ip5000, ip6000, or
ip6000D. Make sure you can test them as working
perfectly- these all take the same cartridges (6BCI) as the previous printers:
i560, i860, i960, i900D, i9100, i9900.
Make sure if you buy an older printer from someone- it prints a perfect test
REGARDING newer Canon Cameras and printers:
Canon printers BEAT ALL in my mind- Canon excels at imaging- Camera and
I do NOT work for Canon.
Avoid any printer under $79unless you are a broke student or just need something cheap for very
use, or you really are not picky about the quality you
You can refill your laser printers with toner yourself, recycling the cartridge,
for 1/5th the cost of just replacing the whole cartridge. This is fairly easy in
most cases. Details at the bottom of this page.
I have tried Continuous Flow systems for Canon printers. Sorry, but I did not
have long term success. They all break down after a MAXIMUM of 3 months. This is
due to the design of Canon cartridges that just do not allow permanent use of
CIS systems. Sorry, I wish it was otherwise, but it isn't. They are more trouble
than they are worth, even if you get them to work in the beginning.
DO NOT expect your paper inkjet prints to look EXACTLY like the preview on your
monitor. Both flat LCD
monitors and regular more common tube CRT monitors PROJECT light to your eyes.
Paper inkjet prints REFLECT light to your eyes-- color transmission is very
different between a monitor and a paper print. Even with the best calibration-
and most people don't even approach this- a print and you monitor will differ
significantly in worst cases, and somewhat in best cases. Adjust your printer
color settings from what you see on actual prints. You can calibrate your
monitor to get close, but chances are, for the best color rendition, look at the
print and adjust accordingly.
Why is this a BRAIN
review? Because often reviews are written
(even by third parties) which are done poorly, and with motives that may
reflect conflict of interests. This is an honest evaluation done by yours
truly, seeking the best quality and results for reasonable cost.
AND I USE ALL OF
THIS STUFF- extensively all of the time, printing hundreds of photos every
month and THOUSANDS of documents and photos every year.
OFTEN, magazine and web
reviews are inaccurate- why? The people writing the reviews are COLUMNISTS, and
rarely use this stuff at a full time level. They make their conclusions based on
short term use, limited use, and frequently don't have the eye of a pro. They
may have a slanted bias for or against a printer for unexplained reasons. THEY
ACCEPT PAID ADVERTISING, duh- what do you think this does to accurate
opinions, eh? I've
seen all kinds of BAD reviews regarding printers, as well as cameras. Take any review in a
commercial site or magazine with a grain of salt. I use my printers ALL the
time, and have for years.
I recently looked at the CNET reviews of
inkjet printers-- TOTAL CRAP. This is really bad information to be giving people
per their ratings, and I genuinely feel sorry for anyone buying a printer based
on these kinds of reviews. Irrelevant and inconsistent, and things CNET editors
judged relevant----OOOOO@! it actually makes me disgusted. The editors at CNET
are morons to publish these ratings- but then, they accept commercial
advertising. BEWARE!! of reviews on commercial sites!
The main players
in the regular inkjet and inkjet photo printer consumer market are Epson,
HP, Canon, and Lexmark. What I looked at was detail, correct color, speed,
price, reputation, reliability and ease of use. I spoke with representatives
from the companies, dealers, and used the equipment. I did this on my own
then compared some reliable
reviews, and found that my results were
in keeping with other reviews.
Any of today's inkjet
printers do a good job for
general non-too-picky use, and if you only use
your printer occasionally, most printers will suffice.
But, if you've got a real eye
for quality and reliability-- WATCH
OUT. For the same money you
will spend on a greatly lesser printer, you can get a printer way ahead of the
Given all things
equal, SIX color (5 colors plus black) printers are superior for
lifelike and accurate color over the FOUR color (three colors plus black)
printers. This difference may not be noticeable or important however to
many people. For snapshots where
color imagery accuracy is not that important, it is a small difference.
You will pay more for six color systems than four color systems, as well
as for the ink. Look at the sample photos at the store- if you can't
tell the difference, and absolute color accuracy is not important to you-
factor this into your printer purchase/use decision. If you've got a decent eye,
and you do care and want the best- go 6 color.
are now 7 and 8 color printers out there-- in my opinion, forget it. This is pure
overkill. 6 color printers will now deliver the same quality as a regular color
photo lab. Add 2 more colors- what... do you drive a Humvee to get to 7-11 and
get your groceries also- when a Honda will get 3 times the gas mileage, easier
to park, a fraction of the cost? Two more colors add more problems to deal with,
that you really don't need. The payoff is minimal, if it exists at all.
As far as ink goes,
we have now found outlets on the web that sell
printer model specific
outstanding quality ink
at a truly reasonable cost-- 1/6th the price of OEM ink or manufacturers
ink elsewhere. It's ink at the price IT SHOULD BE. See details below.
If you are replacing inkjet cartridges more than once every year (ha ha)
you should not be wasting money supporting greedy printing companies by
shelling out $50 for an ounce of ink. !!! How Canon, and Epson, and all
the rest rationalize charging outrageous prices for pennies worth of ink
is a story in corporate greed in itself. Okay, they make good printers--
charge fair prices for ink already.
INK AND PRINT LIFE
this discussion comes up immediately when dealing with THIRD PARTY INK
SUPPLIERS. Don't make the assumption that anything other than name brand ink
will last a fraction of the life span predicted by $12 -$50 name brand ink
are ENORMOUS variables in what constitutes print life. Conditions, ink itself,
brand, paper, and how all of these interact. There is NO ONE ANSWER, and it is a
bad assumption to make that if you use the printer's ink and paper, you will get
the best results. Of course, that is what Canon, Epson, and HP would want you to
believe. God bless them, they've made great at-home photo printing possible- but
that's no excuse to gouge us for ink.
been using cheap Epson Glossy Photo paper ($20 for 120 8.5 X 11" sheets at
COSTCO) for years. I use third party CUSTOM FORMULA INK (not the generic off the
shelf one-ink-fits-all from Office Depot), which costs about 1/6 - 1/20 the
price of name brand ink depending on the packaging (4 oz bulk bottles cheaper,
obviously). I keep my prints hung on the wall with scotch tape in a brightly
sunlit room. I have yet to see and print fading or discoloration in 2 years of
any of my s900 or i960 prints. Maybe in ten years. The Canon FORMULA is
expected to last 25-27 years before ink degeneration- I would say this is very
If you need
DETAILED information on print life, then you need to do serious homework. Don't
take mainstream media propaganda (PC magazine for example) as God's word. Think
about WHO buys advertising in their magazine....Their own article on this
subject was VERY limited in it's sensationalist testing. Start here instead: http://www.wilhelm-research.com/index.html
read this: The MYTH of non-permanence of inkjet
you are printing PROFESSIONALLY and selling your prints-- DO YOUR HOMEWORK.
Both Canon and Epson now sell pro printers that use archival inks.
you are a home consumer use- use regular dyebase inks. They'll look better,
printer cheaper, and last plenty long enough provided you don't put your prints
in direct sunlight- even REAL color lab photos won't last in the sun- duh.
are four companies whom I have bought ink for my Canon printer at fair prices,
and I've had excellent results with each. Each company offers some unique
advantage for your situation, so look at them all, and see my detailed notes
about INK below.
with the actual manufacturer who supplies these distributors with their inks-
very honest, well informed people. I have no doubts- none- about the integrity
of their products and their equivalent quality to name brand inks.
ARCHIVAL INKS: All consumer inkjet printers start off using DYE based inks.
Archival PIGMENT inks are made, and offer better life-- at higher price. I
personally don't use them.
Do lots of homework if pigment inks interest
success is really a BRAIN thing- click it on
SECTION "Ink Test Update" CLICK THIS
Off to: The Amazing Brain Music Adventure